After Chandler Stanton's 45-yard field goal put the Mountaineers on top with 5:45 to play, the defense held but Robert Lefevre's 45-yard punt pinned Appalachian State on its 8-yard line with four minutes remaining.
Noel then carried five-straight times, the last two 41- and 22-yard bursts that put the Mountaineers (3-1) on the Marshall 5. Quarterback Chase Brice then knelt down three times to run out the clock.
After the second of Brice's touchdowns, Rasheen Ali had a 97-yard kickoff return to give Marshall a 20-14 lead. But Brice capped a third long drive with a touchdown two seconds before halftime to put Appalachian State back on top 21-20.
Ali's touchdown run gave Marshall (2-2) a 30-21 lead entering the fourth quarter.
The former conference rivals from the FCS days were meeting for the second time as FBS schools with Marshall winning 17-7 last season.
LSU's football coaching search: Who could replace Ed Orgeron?
With LSU and Ed Orgeron reaching an agreement to part ways following the season, one of the game's best jobs is now open. Could former Texas A&M and current LSU AD Scott Woodward look to reunite with Jimbo Fisher in Baton Rouge?
Cincinnati Bearcats jump to No. 2 in AP Top 25 college football poll; Purdue Boilermakers end rankings drought
Cincinnati moved up to No. 2 in The Associated Press college football poll Sunday, the first time a team from outside the traditional power conferences has been ranked that high since 2010.
AP Top 25 college football poll reaction: What's next for each ranked team?
With the release of the latest AP poll, here's what is next up for each team in the new rankings.
Bowl projections and analysis: Who moves up with Iowa Hawkeyes going down?
With Purdue knocking off No. 2 Iowa, we reshuffle our bowl matchups and break down the playoff, the most intriguing matchups and more.
Ed Orgeron won't return as LSU Tigers' football coach next season, sources say
Only 21 months after guiding LSU to a perfect record and national championship, Ed Orgeron and the Tigers have reached an agreement for him to step aside after this season, sources confirmed to ESPN.
College football SP+ rankings after Week 7
Despite the week-to-week chaos of the 2021 season, the truly elite teams are starting to separate themselves in the SP+ rankings.