All things considered, his teammates and coaches say, Kyle McCord's NFL debut showed promise.
The 2025 sixth-round pick completed 17-of-32 passes for 209 yards in his first career start Sunday, and scored a 3-yard rushing touchdown in a 24-22 loss to the Indianapolis Colts. It was also McCord's first game action with Miami, which traded for him in August after the preseason ended.
Dolphins coach Jeff Hafley said he appreciated McCord's demeanor, particularly after Indianapolis recovered a strip sack in the end zone to take a 21-7 lead on the opening play of the second half.
"Love his composure. I like our team's composure and resiliency, and I thought Kyle was a great example of that today," Hafley said Sunday. "Things didn't always go right. We came out in the half, and they had a defensive score, and that could have been ugly with the score. And we fought all the way back, and Kyle did a great job, I thought there, so there's going to be some positives, and there's going to be some things that we need to correct.
"But for his first outing, I thought he kept his composure, which was really, really important to me."
McCord's outing featured a handful of marquee plays; he completed a 31-yard pass to Malik Washington that had just a 20.9% completion probability, according to Next Gen Stats. Washington tracked the ball with one hand and came down with the catch near the sideline.
The former Syracuse and Ohio State product also completed a 38-yard pass to Caleb Douglas on third-and-13 that set up his rushing touchdown two plays later.
Douglas was the Dolphins' top receiver Sunday, catching three passes for 71 yards on eight targets. The third-round pick leads all rookies in receiving yards per game with 61.2 and told the Miami Herald that McCord was "very calm, very poised" in his first start.
Hafley said Douglas provides a reliable target for McCord as he settles into the starting job over at least the next three games.
"I think he's a guy that our quarterbacks have been comfortable throwing the ball to," Hafley said Monday. "He's shown that he can go up and catch it in traffic. He's got the ability to catch and run and break tackles. And he's a guy they trust because he's where he's supposed to be, when he's supposed to be there, and that's really important in the pass game.
"There were a couple times yesterday where Kyle was getting the ball out on time, it was bang bang and (the ball) was right there. So he trusts him, and I thought the connection was really good yesterday."
Starting quarterback Malik Willis remains on injured reserve until at least Week 14 with a groin injury that Hafley said extended into his core. As of Monday, Hafley said there are no plans for Willis to undergo surgery -- but the first-year coach admitted that could change.
For at least the next three weeks, Hafley said he wants McCord to focus on his development and improving week over week. McCord called his first game a "learning experience," and said he felt like despite his limited action with the starting unit, he was capable of running the Dolphins' entire offensive playbook.
He said last week that there's some relief to the certainty of his reps for the next month, but it won't change how he prepares each week.
"I would definitely say there's benefit to knowing you're playing beforehand and being able to get those live reps of the guys rather than kind of just being thrown into the fire without any reps of the ones," McCord said. "But I think regardless if it's a four-game stretch, a five-game stretch, a one-game stretch, whatever it is, I feel like you still approach it the same way. And you're not looking at who we got next week and the week after that. I'm just focused on this Sunday and taking it day by day."
